When I was in Elementary school one of my favorite shows was Arthur. I always watched it before school in the morning and looked forward to it after school as well. The characters were really fun and diverse and the storylines were always relatable too. Many of those storylines came from the books so it was neat to see those stories come to life; my favorites being Arthur’s Eyes and Arthur’s Chicken Pox. Arthur also covered a variety of sensitive topics that many children’s shows shied away from ; examples of these include 9/11, cancer, dementia and various disabilities. Overall Arthur was a great series that lasted 25 seasons, this year would actually mark the 30th anniversary of first episode airing on PBS Kids or PTV as it was known at the time.
However looking back there are a few episodes that are a little questionable to me now as an adult. And by questionable I don’t mean they are necessarily inappropriate, it’s more so that there are situations that could have been either completely avoided or handled a lot differently with better parenting. The first example I’m going to talk about is an episode from season 2 called “Lost.” Basically Arthur is forced to take the city bus alone to his swim lesson because his mom isn’t able to take him due to having to be at DW’s school play. Arthur ends up falling asleep on the bus, missing his stop and being forced to get off at the very last stop, which is in a completely unfamiliar part of town to Arthur. He then walks into a diner and tries to call his grandmother on a broken pay phone. Fortunately a nice lady at the diner helps him to catch another bus and he makes it home. Happy ending I guess but the main issue here is what kind of parents allow their 8 year old to ride a city bus alone with a bunch of strangers?! It’s possible this is an episode that just hasn’t aged well and this was more acceptable in the 90s when it aired. But I can’t imagine any parent doing that these days. 8 is way too young to be on public transport by yourself, Arthur could have been abducted or assaulted without a responsible adult present. Arthur’s parents could have arranged for someone else to take him to his swimming lesson or they could have at least gotten a responsible adult to ride the bus with him. That would have easily prevented the whole situation. Sending him on that bus alone just seems like incredibly irresponsible parenting. Also the broken pay phone bit would never happen these days. If this episode were to be made today someone at the diner could have let Arthur borrow their phone so he could call home. But there weren’t any cell phones back then so Arthur was pretty much out of luck. It was lucky however that Arthur was able to find help from that nice lady. But he could have easily been abducted at the diner as well since he was there alone and may not have gotten so lucky to find a way home. It was just a really weird and scary episode and I just don’t think it would work in today’s society.
The other episode I want to talk about is a slightly later episode from season 7 called Cast Away. The episode begins with Dad and Arthur getting ready to head to the science museum for some time for just the two of them. But unfortunately they are forced to take DW because Baby Kate is sick and their mom needs to get some work done. DW ends up ruining the day for Arthur because she gets scared at the Under Sea exhibit Arthur wanted to go to and Dad is forced to take her to the unicorn exhibit instead. First of all couldn’t the parents have arranged for DW to go to Grandma Thora’s or at least to a friend’s house, especially if they knew she was too young for the undersea exhibit Arthur wanted to go to? Fortunately Dad realizes Arthur is upset and promises to take him camping the following weekend without DW and then spend the weekend after with DW. Unfortunately Dad finds out he has to work the weekend he is supposed to spend with DW and of course DW cries and throws a big fit about missing her weekend with Dad. So the whole family ends up going on the camping trip including DW. This is what bothered me about this episode. Dad promised that weekend just for Arthur and it seemed incredibly unfair that DW had to come along, especially after she already ruined the museum trip for Arthur. Arthur really deserved a weekend away from his sister. But instead the parents gave into DW’s crying fit and let her come on the trip. That’s not great parenting either. They needed to teach DW that she can’t always get what she wants rather than giving into her all the time, which I think is reinforcing her bratty behavior. I realize that DW is only 4 and probably isn’t exactly mature yet but still the mom could have just done something else with DW that day. The Dad also could have promised to spend a different weekend with DW. Of course DW once again completely ruined the trip for Arthur by being better at fishing just because she brought her Mary Moo Cow music, while Arthur ends up twisting his ankle and being unable to fish anymore. There is also a scene at the end where the dad commends Arthur for allowing his little sister to come on a trip that was intended for just the two of them. But did Arthur really have a choice in this? It all just seemed like a really unfair episode completely favoring DW over Arthur.
Those were the two episodes that annoyed me the most? Can you think of any other annoying Arthur episodes with bad parenting?